Voice or writing
voice journaling vs writing a journal.
Write when you like the pen, when the room has to stay quiet, or when you want to fix the sentence as you go. Talk when the blank page is why you quit, when you're tired, or when you already narrate the day out loud and then lose it. Whichever one you still do on a bad night is the one that works.
I make YapJar, so the last section is how the app does this. You can skip it. If you've already decided to talk, the method is in how to start voice journaling.
the short version.
| Writing | Talking | |
|---|---|---|
| when it fits | You like a pen or a keyboard, and you want to cross a sentence out. Or the room is shared, or someone is asleep. | You're walking, or lying down and you won't sit up to write. Or the blank page is why the last notebook stopped. |
| what you decide first | You pick what matters, find the words, then decide if the sentence is fair. An entry doesn't exist until those are done. | You start talking. The point usually shows up halfway through a sentence. |
| what you keep | You keep the page. On paper that's your handwriting. In an app it's a file you can reread, and search if it's text. | A voice memo keeps the audio. A voice journal keeps the words as text. Audio you won't go back and play isn't a record you can use later. |
| editing | You change the sentence while you write. Handy when you want a clear account. Also how a day starts getting performed for an imaginary reader. | You don't edit while you're talking, so a transcript sounds like speech, second try included. Some apps then tidy mishears and filler. Read what the app says it changes before you trust that. |
| privacy in the room | It's quiet. Someone next to you can see that you're writing. They only see the words if they read over your shoulder. | People can hear you. Fine alone, in a car you are not driving, or on a walk with one earphone in. A bad fit on a train, or next to someone who's asleep. |
| coming back later | You can reread a page in a minute, if you can find it. Paper won't search. A notes app will. | A transcript rereads the same way. A folder of memos makes you listen in real time, which is why the folder stops getting opened. |
Don't journal by voice while you're driving. Wait until you're parked, or until you're walking.
what writing is good at.
A pen slows you down, and some days that's what I want. The sentence has to be chosen, so a vague feeling gets a noun. Paper has no account and no subscription, and there's nobody to email it to. If you already like opening a notebook, keep the notebook. Talking is the other tool, for the nights it stays in the bag.
Writing also wins anywhere you can't talk. An open office, a thin wall, a kid asleep in the next room. And it wins when you might hand the entry to someone later, because you shaped it on purpose. A transcript of you thinking out loud makes a bad letter.
what talking is good at.
I rarely run out of things to say. I stall at the start, on a blank page, at the hour when I have the least left, trying to decide what the day meant before I've said a word. Talking skips that part. You already know how to tell a friend how the day went, and a voice journal is that conversation kept.
It is also harder to perform. People edit a paragraph about their own afternoon as if it might be read. They do not edit the walk home. The register you want in a journal is closer to the walk.
The cost is the room, and the tool. If all you keep is the audio, you have a diary you will not revisit. The useful version turns the talking into text and throws the audio away, or never stores it. How to start, including the free ways already on an iPhone, is in how to start voice journaling.
doing both, without doing two journals.
Pick the questions once, and answer them however the day allows. The evening three are what happened, what stuck with you, and what you would not want to forget, written out in evening reflection questions. The morning four look forward, in morning journal prompts. Same questions on paper, in a notes app, or out loud.
- Don't talk for ten minutes and then type it up yourself at midnight. That's a second job, the one you were trying to skip.
- Don't keep a paper journal and a voice journal that ask different things. You won't know where a given day lives.
- If you write three days and talk the fourth, the fourth still counts. The questions are what line the days up.
how yapjar does it.
YapJar is an iPhone journal that asks one question at a time, the evening three or the morning four, and you answer. You can talk, or switch to the keyboard, including in the middle of an entry. A spoken entry has mishears and filler repaired, and nothing else is changed. A typed entry stays exactly as typed. The questions you answered sit beside what you said.
Apple's speech recognition does the transcribing, on your phone where your device supports it, and the audio never reaches YapJar's servers. Your first entry, in your own words, comes before any trial. Keep a pen if you want a pen. This is for the night you won't sit down to write. The questions, with no app required, are in 76 journal prompts.
questions people ask.
is voice journaling better than writing?
It is better when the reason you quit is the blank page, and worse when you cannot talk out loud or you want to shape each sentence as you go. The better journal is the one you still do on a tired night. Neither one is more real.
do I lose something if I do not write by hand?
You lose the pen, the slowness, and a page nobody else can open from a server. You do not lose the record, if the words are kept as text you can read back. Liking one of those is a preference. It is not a requirement for a journal to count.
can I voice journal and write?
Yes. Talk when you are walking or lying down. Write when the room is shared, or when you want to revise the sentence. The questions can be the same either way.
are voice memos a voice journal?
They are a pile of audio with dates for names. A voice journal keeps the words, so a day is something you can read in a minute and find later. Almost nobody goes back and listens to the memos.
does rambling still count as journaling?
Yes. Talking wanders, doubles back, and says um. That is the sound of thinking. In YapJar a spoken entry has mishears and filler repaired so it reads cleanly, and nothing else is changed. If you type, it stays as typed.
talk, or type. the entry is what you said.
one question at a time, morning or night. mishears and ums repaired on a spoken entry, nothing else touched. your first entry comes before any trial. iPhone only for now.
get the app